A 99-year-old pie shop is out-posting you
London’s Noted Eel & Pie House was founded in 1926 and its fourth-generation owner now reaches millions with phone clips of pie tops and liquor pours. If a century-old shop can do it, your bakery can.
Marcus Reed
Pie shop playbook · October 2026
·
13-minute read
Ready-to-edit example
Measurement plan
@leytonstonepiemash
Noted Eel & Pie House telling its 1926-to-now story, one part at a time.
Real video · @leytonstonepiemash on TikTok
Pie is trust food. Nobody impulse-buys a whole pie from a shop they’ve never heard of — they buy from the place their neighbor swears by, the one they’ve watched pull lattice-topped fruit pies out of the oven on their phone at eleven at night. That watching part is new, and it’s the part most pie shops and specialty bakeries still haven’t claimed. Whether you sell bourbon pecan by the slice, chicken pot pies by the case, or traditional pie and mash with liquor, the playbook is the same: show the hands, show the filling, show the history if you have it, and post on a rhythm that survives Thanksgiving week. We’ve built that playbook here, around a real shop that’s been at it since 1926.
Short answer: lead with process and heritage video — filling pours, lattice work, oven pulls, and the story of the shop — posted four times a week with TikTok and Instagram Reels as the priority. Batch-film on bake day, schedule the week in advance, and reserve your remaining energy for the holiday pre-order pushes that actually move revenue.
Key takeaways before you read further
What a century-old shop can teach you about a feed
The pie accounts that grow are the ones that treat the shop itself as the story. Noted Eel & Pie House in Leytonstone — opened in Bow in 1926, moved east in the seventies, now run by fourth-generation owner Alfie Hack — posts under the handle @leytonstonepiemash, and the feed is almost aggressively ordinary: orders being plated, pie tops going on, liquor being ladled, regulars’ quirks. The Romford Recorder reports the account has drawn well over a hundred thousand followers across platforms and millions of likes, with his most popular video reportedly viewed over eight million times. No studio, no scripts. Daily shop life, filmed.
Three mechanics make it work, and all three transfer to any pie bakery. First, repetition with variation: the same few formats — the order, the bake, the history bit — posted relentlessly, so the audience knows the show and still gets a new episode. Second, specificity: real order lingo (“two and two,” “three and two”) in the captions, which outsiders find fascinating and insiders find validating. Your bakery’s equivalent might be “double-crust sour cherry, extra crumble.”
Third, the owner answers things. One of the account’s stronger formats is replying to a commenter’s question with a video — why pie shops sell stewed eels, what liquor actually is. Every pie bakery sits on a pile of these questions. Answering them on camera is the fastest trust-builder in food.
Exhibit A for ordinary-work-as-content: pie tops going on, ready to be trimmed and sent to the oven — a mid-production moment most bakers wouldn’t think to film, posted by a shop that films everything. @leytonstonepiemash on TikTok
Profile makeover
A fictional but realistic pie shop profile, before and after applying our recommendations
BEFORE → AFTER
@thepieplace
Pies made fresh daily. Come visit!
15 posts · 310 followers · No link in bio
@thepieplace.maplewood
Scratch pies, sweet & savory · Baked daily in Maplewood · Whole-pie pre-orders open Thursdays
61 posts · engaged local following · pre-order link in bio
Teardown: 99 years of history in a phone clip
Noted Eel & Pie House — a family-run pie and mash shop in Leytonstone, London, trading since 1926
REAL CASE STUDY
Why this one works
This is part two of the shop’s own origin story — captioned “1977–2025, 99 years and counting” — posted by a fourth-generation owner who understands that his bakery’s strongest asset isn’t the pie, it’s the continuity. Heritage content like this does something process clips can’t: it gives viewers a reason to root for the business. The Romford Recorder reports the account behind it has built a following well into six figures across TikTok and Instagram, with millions of likes, largely on this blend of daily shop life and history — and note the structure here, because it’s shrewd. The story is split into parts, which turns a single history lesson into a returning series and pulls viewers to the profile to find the rest. The hashtags stay broad and honest — pie and mash, London food, British food — anchoring the clip in both a cuisine and a place. Your shop may be five years old, not ninety-nine, but the move is identical: tell the story of why you exist, in chapters, in your own voice.
Steal this: Write your shop’s origin story as a two-part video series — part one ends at the moment you almost didn’t open.
Content formats that fit between the mixer and the oven
Your anchor format is the production clip: filling pours, lattice weaving, crimping, egg wash, the oven pull with steam. Film vertically, close, with natural sound — the scrape of a bench knife is better audio than any trending track. The slice reveal is the payoff shot: a knife dropping through a full pie, the cross-section held to the lens. For double-crust and cream pies, that cross-section is your entire sales pitch in two seconds.
Next, the menu-board format: what’s in the case today, filmed as a slow pan with prices in the caption. It’s unglamorous and it converts, because pie buyers plan. Pair it with a weekly “what sold out first” post — scarcity is honest marketing when it’s true. Third, the question-and-answer reply video, stolen directly from the pie-and-mash playbook: let comments and counter questions write your scripts. Why is fruit pie seasonal? What’s the difference between pot pie and pasty? Do you ship?
Finally, the heritage or origin post, even if your shop opened eighteen months ago. Where the recipes came from, who taught you lamination, why you opened a pie shop in a cupcake world — identity content earns the follows that outlast any single viral clip. One per week is plenty; it’s seasoning, not the meal.
Measuring results in a business that peaks twice a year
Pie retail has a shape: a long steady middle, a Pi Day bump, and a November–December spike that can represent a terrifying share of annual revenue. Your measurement should respect that shape. In the steady months, track leading indicators — local view share, profile visits, saves on menu posts, and growth in your pre-order list — rather than raw reach. Saves matter more for pie than almost any food: a saved post is a planned purchase.
In the six weeks before Thanksgiving, switch to direct-response math. Every post should carry the pre-order link, and you should know — roughly, honestly — how many order-form submissions arrived within a day of each post. You don’t need attribution software; a simple “how did you hear about us” field on the order form, plus the timestamps, gets you most of the answer. If reels drive forms and static posts don’t, that’s next year’s November plan written for you.
Year-round, a unified dashboard keeps this honest. SocialBlaze’s analytics put TikTok, Instagram, and Facebook performance side by side, so you can see whether the slice reveal or the Q&A format is doing the heavy lifting — and its scheduler means the holiday content barrage gets built in October, when you still have hands free to build it.
How to film your first bake-day video
Three steps, one phone, no editor required
QUICK START
SocialBlaze helps you plan, write, and publish across every platform — free to start.
What a sample content week looks like
This calendar is built around a bakery’s real week: heavy bake days, a weekend case rush, and one owner with flour on their hands. Film on your biggest bake day, schedule everything that night, and let the queue carry you.
Your weekly content rhythm
A repeatable seven-day framework you can start using tomorrow
SAMPLE CALENDAR
Your first four weeks
Week 1: Film the bake you were doing anyway
Mount your phone over the bench on your two biggest bake days and record the three beats — filling, top, oven — as separate takes while you work exactly as you always do. Post three cut-together reels this week with specific captions: pie name, filling, when it hits the case. Rewrite your bio to state what you bake, where you are, and how to pre-order, and get a working link in it even if that link is just a web form. Resist the urge to buy a tripod, a mic, or a ring light; the point of week one is proving that content production fits inside production, full stop. If you end the week with three honest bake videos posted, week one worked.
Week 2: Add the case, the slice, and the questions
Keep two production reels, then widen the menu of formats. Post your first case pan with prices, your first slice reveal — reshoot the knife drop until the cross-section is clean — and your first Q&A reply video answering something a real customer actually asked this week. Start a running list of counter questions in your phone; it becomes your script backlog. Reply to every comment inside a day, and search your shop’s name across TikTok, Instagram, and Google to see what customers are already posting. Share the good ones to your story with thanks. By the end of week two you should have five formats live and a feel for which two come easiest.
Week 3: Batch it and schedule it
Consolidate. Film everything on one bake day — two production reels, one slice reveal, the case pan, a handful of stills — and write all seven captions that night while the details are fresh. Load the full week into SocialBlaze and let it publish on schedule while you bake, serve, and sleep. With the daily posting burden gone, spend the recovered hour on two things: building or cleaning your pre-order form, and drafting your origin story as a two-part video series, which you’ll film next week. If a post flops this week, let it; the system matters more than any single result. Note which scheduled time slots get the best early traction in your analytics.
Week 4: Post the story, read the numbers, plan the spike
Publish your two-part origin story Tuesday and Friday — part one ends on a cliffhanger, part two lands the milestone — and pin both to your profile. Then pull four weeks of data and answer three questions: which format drove the most saves and profile visits, what share of your viewers are local, and did the pre-order form feel any posts at all. Set your permanent rhythm — four posts a week is sustainable for most solo bakers — and open a calendar note for the next seasonal spike, whether that’s Thanksgiving, Pi Day, or hand-pie season at the summer market. The holiday content gets drafted now, in the quiet, and scheduled later. That’s the whole trick.
Frequently asked questions
My pies look great but my shop is tiny and cluttered. Won’t that hurt the videos?
The opposite, usually. Clutter reads as authenticity in food video — flour dust, stacked trays, a cramped bench with good hands working on it signal “real bakery” in a way a spotless studio kitchen never will. The pie-and-mash shop in our case study films in a decades-old interior and the setting is part of the appeal. What does hurt videos is bad light and shaky framing, both of which are free to fix: film near the window or under your brightest work light, and prop the phone instead of holding it. Clean the two square feet the camera sees, and let the rest of the shop be a shop.
How early should I start posting holiday pre-order content?
Open the conversation about six weeks out and open orders about four weeks out — pie buyers plan, and the people ordering for a holiday table are the planningest of all. Use the early posts to tease the lineup and collect flavor votes, which doubles as demand forecasting. Once orders open, state the cutoff date in every single post and story; the number-one failure mode is customers discovering the deadline after it passed. Draft and schedule the whole campaign in October while the kitchen is calm. During the spike itself you should be baking, not writing captions, so let the queue do the posting and reserve your live energy for stories and replies.
Savory pies are my main business. Does all this sweet-pie advice still apply?
Almost all of it, and the savory shop arguably has it easier. The case study in this guide is a savory shop — pie and mash with liquor — and its best formats transfer directly: the order being plated, the production line, the explainer answering what’s actually in the pie. Savory gives you lunch-rush urgency that sweet shops lack, so lean on time-sensitive content: what’s hot at noon, how many pot pies are left, when the next batch lands. The slice reveal becomes the fork-break or the gravy pour. The one adjustment: your audience peaks on weekday lunch decisions, so schedule your strongest posts mid-morning rather than evening.
Should I show prices in my posts? I’m worried about seeming expensive.
Show them. Hiding prices doesn’t make a scratch pie cheaper; it just moves the sticker shock to the counter, where it costs you an awkward conversation instead of a scroll-past. Pricing in captions filters for the right customers and signals confidence, and the case-pan-with-prices format consistently earns saves precisely because it lets people plan a purchase. If your pies cost more than the supermarket’s, your content is the argument for why: butter lamination on camera, fruit being pitted by hand, the four hours a pot pie actually takes. Make the process visible and the price becomes self-explanatory. Defensive silence persuades no one.
I can bake or I can make content — I genuinely don’t have time for both. What’s the minimum?
The honest minimum is one filming session and one scheduling session per week — call it two hours total. Mount the phone on bake day, capture the three beats plus one slice reveal, write captions that night, and queue four posts through a scheduler so they publish without you. Skip everything else: no trends, no daily stories, no fourth platform. A pie shop posting four solid process videos a week, every week, will outgrow a shop posting fourteen scattered things one month and nothing the next. Consistency is the entire game for local food retail, and batching plus scheduling is the only way a working baker sustains it.
Bake the pies. Queue the posts. Let both run.
A fourth-generation pie shop built a six-figure audience by filming the work it was already doing — your bakery’s version of that feed is one bake-day filming session away. Batch it once a week and let SocialBlaze schedule every post while the ovens are on.
Marcus Reed writes practical social media field guides for small businesses at SocialBlaze — the organic social media scheduling and analytics platform built for independent brands.
Case-study videos are embedded from their creators’ public accounts and remain the property of their creators. Figures mentioned reflect publicly visible information at the time of publication (October 2026). SocialBlaze is an organic social media management tool — it does not run ads or manage paid campaigns.
